Shimano RC5 Review: Best Cycling Shoes for Casual Riders
After much research and debate (you can read about it in this post), I finally got my hands on the Shimano RC5 cycling shoes. I’ve now had the chance to ride with them, and in this post, I’ll share my honest impressions – covering fit, comfort, performance, and whether they deserve a spot among the best cycling shoes for weekend riders like me.
First Impressions Out of the Box
The Shimano RC5 came well-packaged, and the materials felt premium for a mid-tier shoe. The mesh upper was lightweight and breathable. The BOA dial felt smooth, and the Velcro strap added a secure feeling around the forefoot.
Visually, the blue color grew on me – especially after matching it with my socks and jersey. It’s not as clean as white, but definitely looks pro enough for casual riders.
Fit and Sizing of Shimano RC5: Are They Right for Wide Feet?
My feet are on the wide side – about 28 cm long and 9 cm wide. I chose size EU45, and I’m happy to report the fit was just right – snug enough to feel secure, but still comfortable even with socks.
The insole support felt solid, and there was enough toe wiggle room. The heel held firm, with no noticeable lift during hard pedaling. I used standard mid-thickness cycling socks.
💬 Note: If you have wide feet, Shimano’s regular RC5 already fits wider than brands like Giro or Fizik. You might not even need the “E” wide version unless your feet are extremely wide.
On the Bike: Ride Feel and Performance
I tested the RC5 during a few outdoor rides, each about 45 to 60 minutes long, at an average speed of 25–30 km/h. I rode mostly on flat roads with some mild inclines. Here’s how the shoes performed:
- Stiffness: The carbon-reinforced sole felt firm enough for solid power transfer. It’s not a full carbon race sole, but it offered more responsiveness than my old shoes.
- Comfort: The fit stayed comfortable from start to finish. No pressure points or numbness. Even with socks, there was enough space in the toe box.
- BOA dial: Super convenient. I made minor tension adjustments on the go – much easier than fussing with straps.
- Ventilation: Even under hot weather, my feet didn’t overheat. The mesh upper really helps with airflow.
- Walking: Like most road shoes, walking is limited, but it wasn’t slippery or awkward when unclipped.
Styling and Flexibility of Shimano RC5
While I originally wanted white shoes, the blue RC5 doesn’t disappoint. It looks sporty and pairs well with black, navy, or grey kits. If I ever want that white look, I can always throw on white shoe covers.
✅ Tip: Match your socks to your shoe or bib to tie the look together. Blue can be a versatile base color.
Pros and Cons
✅ Pros
- Great fit for wide feet
- BOA dial offers quick, precise adjustment
- Stiff and efficient for casual to serious weekend rides
- Good ventilation
- Lightweight feel (under 300g per shoe)
❌ Cons
- Color options may be limited in your size
- Not as stiff as high-end race shoes
- No replaceable heel pad (important for long-term durability)
Verdict: Are These the Best Cycling Shoes for Weekend Riders?
If you’re a casual or enthusiast road cyclist looking for a reliable, comfortable, and responsive shoe without going full race-spec, the Shimano RC5 is an excellent choice. It strikes a perfect balance between performance and comfort, especially for wide feet. For me, it solved my shoe dilemma – and now I can focus more on riding than foot pain.
What’s Next?
I’ll continue riding with the RC5 over the next few weeks and update this post if anything changes – especially during longer routes or hotter weather. If you’re considering upgrading your shoes, or you’re new to road cycling, the Shimano RC5 should be high on your list of the best cycling shoes.
About the Author
1 thought on “Are Shimano RC5 the Best Cycling Shoes for Casual Riders?”